AdThis page has affiliate links. We're paid if you click or buy through them, at no extra cost to you. How we make money

Holiday rental or hotel? How to choose for families, groups and longer stays

Space, kitchens, cleaning fees, check-in and cancellation compared, so you can work out which suits your trip and what it really costs.

Different strengths

Hotels and holiday rentals can both work well, but they suit different trips. A hotel gives you services and flexibility; a rental gives you space and independence. The right choice depends on who is travelling, for how long and what you want from the stay.

When a rental makes sense

  • Families and groups: a house or apartment with several bedrooms can cost less per person than several hotel rooms, and gives everyone a shared living space.
  • Longer stays: a kitchen and washing machine make a week or more much easier and cut eating-out costs.
  • Privacy and space: gardens, pools and separate rooms suit groups who want to spread out.

When a hotel makes sense

  • Short stays and city breaks: no cleaning fee to spread over a few nights, and a central location is easier to find.
  • Flexible arrivals: a 24-hour reception makes late arrivals simple.
  • Services: daily cleaning, breakfast, a concierge and someone to call if something breaks.
  • Solo travellers and couples, where a room is all you need.

Compare the full price

Rental listings often show a nightly price that does not include everything. Look at the total for your dates, including:

  • Cleaning fees, which can make a short stay expensive.
  • Service fees charged by the booking platform.
  • Security deposits.
  • Local tourist taxes, sometimes paid separately on arrival.

Hotels also add tourist taxes in many cities, so compare totals on both sides.

Check-in and house rules

Rentals often have set check-in times and may use key boxes or meet-and-greet arrangements. Check what happens if your flight is late. House rules can cover noise, parties, pets and the number of guests. Read them before booking, particularly for group trips.

Cancellation policies

Both hotels and rentals offer a range of policies. Rentals are more often non-refundable or partly refundable close to the date. If your plans might change, filter for flexible cancellation and read exactly when the deadline falls.

Reading reviews

Look for comments on whether the photos are accurate, how responsive the host is, cleanliness, beds and noise. Several recent reviews are more useful than a high average from a few old ones.

Vrbo specialises in whole-home rentals, while Booking.com and Hotels.com list hotels alongside apartments. Compare totals for the same dates and number of guests.

Related guides